Drilling, workover and well service equipment · Baoji, Shanxi, China
info@bomcochina.com Service centres: UAE · Kuwait · Oman · Saudi Arabia · Egypt
Comparison

ESP or PCP: Which Artificial Lift Fits

Both pumps lift liquid from the bottom of the well. In our quoting experience the choice turns on rate, viscosity and what the well does to the pump rather than on the pump itself.

An ESP is a multistage centrifugal pump driven by a downhole motor on a cable. It produces volume, and it produces it from depth: 50 m3/d in a small unit up to 2,000 m3/d from 3,000 m is routine. It is also the most demanding lift method on power quality, on cable handling and on the fluid it passes.

A PCP is a single-screw positive displacement pump driven by a rod string from surface. It produces a fixed volume per revolution regardless of back pressure, and it tolerates viscous fluid and sand better than any other lift method. Its limit is rod torque and elastomer temperature, which is why 2,000 m is the practical depth ceiling in most fields.

Numbers

Compared on eight criteria

CriterionESPPCP
Rate, m3/d20 - 2,0005 - 500
Depth, mto 3,500 and deeperto 2,000
Viscosity, cPbelow 200to 5,000 and above
Sand tolerancelow to moderate, abrasion stages neededmoderate to high, hardened rotor
Gas handlingneeds a separator or gas handler above 10% GVFpoor, gas lock at low intake pressure
Power supplygrid or generator, 3-phase, stablesurface motor, any prime mover
Workover costhigh, cable and string pulled togetherlow, rods pulled with a workover rig
Failure modemotor or cable, suddenelastomer or rod, progressive
Selection

Where each one clearly wins

Run life is the number we look at first, not the pump price. An ESP in a clean well runs three to five years; in a gassy or sandy well it may run twelve months. A PCP in viscous fluid runs longer than an ESP and fails progressively, which gives the operator time to plan the pull. The cost of a failed ESP includes the cable, the motor and a workover; the cost of a failed PCP is usually a rotor and a rod string.

Where the field has both options, our tie-breaker is the workover spread. A PCP that needs a 900 kN rig every 18 months is cheaper to own than an ESP that needs a 1,800 kN rig and a cable spool every 30 months, even when the ESP has the better run life on paper.

Equipment

Lines this guide points to

Questions we get

Questions buyers ask

Can a PCP handle 1,000 m3/d?

Not in a single unit. PCP capacity is limited by elastomer speed and rod torque; above about 500 m3/d the answer is an ESP or several PCPs in separate wells.

Which handles sand better?

PCP, with a hardened rotor and an abrasion-resistant elastomer. An ESP needs abrasion-resistant stages and still wears faster than a PCP in the same sand cut.

Which is cheaper to install at 1,500 m?

PCP, by a wide margin. No cable, no motor, no downhole sensor, and the surface drive is a standard prime mover.

What kills a PCP first?

Elastomer failure from temperature or from running dry. We see both in the same inspection report. The rod string usually survives; the stator does not.

Related reading

Send the duty and we will confirm the model

Both pumps lift liquid from the bottom of the well. In our quoting experience the choice turns on rate, viscosity and what the well does to the pump…

Request a Quote →
BOMCO
Request a Quote